Noel C. Cilker

In my last entry we began examining the power of eloquent open letters written by American Muslims in opposition to some of President Trump's administration picks , and by Norman Ah-Sing during the gold rush criticizing the governor's wish to end Asian immigration to California . Despite 164 years of separation, the letters share some common themes: Both minority groups - Muslim and Chinese - were eager to tell their opposition how they embrace American values and therefor fit in with other Americans. Both minority groups positively contribute to society by working in common, everyday occupations. In this entry we continue with two more. 3. "We regret to inform you that you are misguided." The American Muslims and Norman Ah-Sing voice their criticism in no uncertain terms. American Muslims to President Trump in 2016: "It is deeply concerning that you have announced the appointment of individuals to your upcoming Administration with a well do...

Previously I wrote how President Trump's travel ban was not a new idea to American history. Over a century earlier, President Arthur signed the Chinese Exclusion Act in response to fears that the Chinese were gobbling up jobs and leaving red-blooded Americans out of work. But even before that, in the thick of the gold rush, California Governor John Bigler announced that he wanted to "check this tide of Asiatic immigration." What's fascinating is what happens when people respond to restrictive actions by those in power. Usually the most vocal are either VERY supportive or VERY opposed, and often sink into the mud with insults or disrespect for the other side. There are people, however, who rise above the rancor. Many times they are the people who are the most targeted, and rather than lose themselves in a sea of angry voices, they call on thought and reason to register their protest. These are often in the form of open letters which sometimes become seminal d...